A manufacturing cell is not just made up of machine tools. For its proper functioning, a set of support systems is also required to guarantee control over the scheduling, administration and inspection processes of the operation carried out in it.
KUKA. (n.d.). Adaptable mobile robots for manufacturing support. Retrieved from
https://www.kuka.com/es-es/productos-servicios/movilidad/robots-m%c3%b3viles/kmr-iiwa
For educational purposes only.
The support systems can be software or hardware that help the product design processes, planning, administration, and production control. They also evaluate the quality of the products and help with the handling of the materials.
In this topic you will learn about some main manufacturing support technologies: CAD systems (of great importance for the design and programming of CNC machines), CAM (whose main application is in the generation of numerical control codes automatically from a CAD) and CAE systems (which use techniques such as DFM and DFA, finite element and mass properties’ analysis to support experts in engineering tasks).
Today, one of the key elements to ensure successful manufacturing is computer vision systems. Thanks to this technology, the quantitative and qualitative characteristics of the products being manufactured in the manufacturing cell can be inspected in real time and at 100%. Finally, there are the storage and material handling systems, since poorly disposed inputs can be the cause of complex misalignment in production schedules, the generation of downtime and damage to components. It is considered that one of the highest costs associated with the manufacture of products is due to a malfunction in the material handling systems.
13.1 CAD/CAM/CAE systems
CAD Systems
Computer-aided design or CAD is defined as an activity that involves the effective use of the computer to create, modify, analyze or document the different stages of the engineering design process (figure 1). It is commonly associated with the use of graphic systems for the generation of digital drawings, but its use has spread over time to many more functions.
Figure 1. Stages of the engineering design process.
Among the benefits of the application of CAD systems in companies, the following can be mentioned.
As mentioned above, CAD systems were initially created with a focus on some exclusive areas of design such as technical drawing and its documentation, but it is also possible to perform other complementary tasks related to interactive presentation and design analysis.
The CAD systems can be classified according to their ability to represent digital models in space as two-dimensional (2D) or three-dimensional (3D) systems. In turn, 3D modeling can be divided according to its complexity into wire models (wireframe), surface models or solid models. All these classifications will be described in more detail below.
Two-dimensional or 2D models
Two-dimensional or 2D models are basically substitutes for a drawing board and are mainly used for the creation of technical documentation (figure 2).
Figure 2. Technical drawing in two dimensions
SIEMENS. (n.d.). Technical drawing in two dimensions.
Retrieved from https://solidedge.siemens.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/develop3d-cad-drawing.png
For educational purposes only.
In 2D CAD systems, all the geometric information available to the computer is two-dimensional, that is, it is contained in a drawing. However, despite the limitations of these systems in terms of design, their scope of application is very broad, for example, to perform plant layouts, in the design of electrical or electronic circuits, hydraulic and pneumatic systems, as well as in the design and projects of assembly lines or molds, among many other applications.
3D models
3D CAD systems make it possible to define objects spatially, simulating an environment closer to what can be perceived. The information that is represented depends on the level of complexity and the amount of data that the model has.
Among the advantages of 3D models, the following can be mentioned.
Table 1 shows the different types of 3D modeling and some of their characteristics.
Models of wires or wireframe |
In wireframe CAD models, the computer has the X, Y, Z coordinates of the object's vertices, as well as the information of the geometric elements that join these vertices. Wire cage modeling has ceased to exist as such to become part of surface modelers, serving on many occasions as a base structure for them. |
Surface models |
Surface CAD models incorporate the wireframe information to subsequently define the faces of the object by means of a surface. They are the most used nowadays when three-dimensional modeling of complex parts is required; when they have been correctly generated, they serve as a starting point for the application of CAM, CAE, rapid prototyping, drawing generation, among other applications. |
Modeling of solids |
Solid modeling is a relatively recent branch of geometric modeling that emphasizes the general applicability of models and insists on creating only "complete" models of solids, for example, models suitable for algorithmically answering any geometric question posed. The solid modeling has the information of the surface model and also distinguishes the inside from the outside of the part. This allows operations such as the generation of sections of all types, assembly of parts in assemblies for interference analysis, work and movement fields, exploded representation for assembly diagrams, as well as obtaining information such as volume, center of gravity and moments of inertia, among others. |
Table 1. Different types of 3D modeling
Computer-aided manufacturing or CAM is defined as the efficient use of the computer for machine planning and programming, as well as the control of the manufacturing process. They are strongly associated with manufacturing engineering functions and with numerical control programming processes.
The initial purpose of CAM systems was numerical control, but over time, their field of action has been extended to other areas within the company. Currently, we can see it incorporated in systems involving robotic arms, automatic systems for storage or material handling and inspection systems, among many other areas.
In general, CAM systems comprise all those manufacturing processes supported by a computer that assist machine programming and enable machine control. Their application can be divided into two categories.
Manufacturing planning
In this application, the computer is used indirectly to support production, for instance, there is no direct connection between it and the process being performed. Computers operate offline to generate information regarding the management of production activities, for example:
Table 2 summarizes other applications of CAM systems in manufacturing process planning.
Click on each type of configuration for more information.
Labor standards are related to the manufacturing time of a part, whether it is made by a machine or an operator. Having a correct standard time helps to schedule production efficiently, the payment of wages, the time between raw material orders and inventory control; for this purpose, there are several CAM software that allow determining these standards.
The task of estimating the costs of a new product can be carried out by CAM systems, for which data such as labor costs, raw material, energy, and labor standards are fed; with this, the CAM system can determine the manufacturing cost of a product.
There are CAM systems on the market that allow inventory planning, they can be highly automated and know the quantity of parts in the raw material warehouse, finished product or work-in-process inventories. They can also make purchase requisitions automatically, ensuring that there is never a shortage of material.
When you have an assembly line, it is important to balance the workload between workstations to avoid bottlenecks and ensure a smooth workflow between stations. CAM systems analyze workloads and assign tasks to each station using methodologies such as COMSOAL, positional weighting, assignment of work according to the shortest action or by tasks of longer duration.
CAM systems allow virtual programming of different technologies. This virtual programming analyzes the movements of the machines and optimizes their work process and then converts them into programs that are sent to the appropriate stations.
Offline robot programming
RoboDK. (n.d.). Offline Robot Programming. Retrieved from https://robodk.com/doc/es/Getting-Started.html
For educational purposes only.
Manufacturing control
Manufacturing control physically manages the company's operations. Among the functions it can perform are the following:
Inspection system with the use of computer vision
https://www.cognex.com/es-mx/products/machine-vision/vision-software/visionpro-software
For educational purposes only.
The benefits of CAM systems include the following points:
To be considered as a basic CAM system, an application or software must incorporate the functions described below.
CAE systems
A CAE (Computer-Aided Engineering) system includes a set of digital tools that allow to rigorously analyze, simulate, and evaluate the functional parameters of a computational version of the product to be manufactured before sending it to production. If any faults are found, we will go back to the previous design stages to correct them.
Some of its applications are as follows:
A CAE process is divided into three stages.
A summary of the tools that are used during any of these stages are the following:
Integration of CAD/CAM systems
CAD/CAM systems are a technology used to automate the design and manufacture of a product. It uses computational resources (software and hardware) to speed up and optimize both processes. The CAD part uses a computer to perform the design functions; on the other hand, the CAM uses the computer processes for the manufacturing functions.
The combination of both in the same process enables the opportunity of reacting faster before possible errors in design or manufacturing. In addition, it reduces product development cycle times, minimizes design costs, ensures an efficient manufacturing process with minimal waste, and increases tool lifetime, among other benefits.
State-of-the-art CAD/CAE/CAM systems
The emergence of CAD/CAE/CAM systems are the next evolutionary step of software tools for manufacturing. Its name indicates the order in which these technologies are applied to a complete process: first we have the drawing of a product through a CAD system (for this it is important that the generated model is 3D and in solids, because this type of drawings have all the necessary information to simulate the behavior of the product to a stimulus virtually, which will verify that the design and materials are correct). Subsequently, the model is subjected to functionality and performance tests using CAE systems. If the product passed the CAE virtual simulations, it goes to the CAM stage where the method, sequence, and type of machines to manufacture the product will be evaluated by CAPP systems. The machines can also be programmed using CAD/CAM technology.
The incorporation of these three technologies greatly enhances product design and manufacturing and brings great benefits to a company. On the contrary, CAD/CAE/CAM systems are sufficiently mature technologies that the investment is fully justified.
13.2 Vision systems
Vision systems are used in industry as one of the most effective non-contact inspection methods. They generally consist of a sensor, a processor, lenses, lighting systems and software. They can examine the products and verify their quantitative characteristics such as length, width, height, radius, and diameter; they can also inspect the qualitative characteristics such as color, surface and absence or presence of components.
COGNEX vision system
https://www.cognex.com/es-mx/products/deep-learning/in-sight-d900
For educational purposes only.
Vision systems date back to the 60s, although at that time no one was able to assume that machine vision could be of any use in industry. It was not until the early 90s that vision technology began to be widely implemented in the industry. At that time most applications were relatively simple in terms of number of processes and execution time but had such a high price that they could hardly be amortized in a reasonable time.
An important reason why parts are inspected by computer monitoring is that when large quantities of products are involved, a fast inspection system is required to verify that the workmanship is correct.
The components of a vision system are the following (figure 3):
Figure 3. Components of a vision system
https://www.innomiles.com/artificial-intelligence-by-machine-vision
For educational purposes only.
Application of the vision systems can be classified as follows:
Another classification of vision systems, but based on their characteristics, is as follows:
Smart camera
www.cognex.com
For educational purposes only.
Multi-camera system
www.cognex.com
For educational purposes only.
PC-based system
https://industrial.omron.es/es/products/FH-5550-20
For educational purposes only
Other applications where these systems are used are related to the military and aerospace industry, in which response speed is critical.
Lighting techniques
The illumination system is one of the most important, since it can highlight those features that are of interest to inspect, while hiding those that are of no interest; 90% of the success of a vision system depends on the illumination technique. Some of the most common are the following (figure 4).
Figure 4. Lighting techniques used in a vision system
Groover, M. (2018). Automation Production System and Computer Integrated Manufacturing (5th ed.). United States: Pearson.
For educational purposes only.
13.3 Storage and material handling system
According to Goover (2018), materials handling comprises all basic operations related to the movement, storage, control and protection of materials, goods and products throughout the manufacturing, distribution, consumption, and disposal process. The field of materials handling focuses on the methods, mechanical equipment, systems, and related controls used to accomplish these functions.
Some of the following recommendations should be considered when designing a material handling system.
The function of a material storage system is to conserve inputs, goods, or products for a period of time, making optimal use of space and ensuring access to them when needed. Some production plants and storage facilities use manual methods to store and retrieve materials, but the trend for several years has been toward more effective, automated methods that maximize the efficiency of the storage function. Storage and transportation of materials.
The list of the principles is displayed when accessing the link,
nexon AUTOMATION. (2018). THE TEN PRINCIPLES OF MATERIAL HANDLING. Retrieved from https://www.nexonautomation.com/the-ten-principles-of-material-handling/
The following link do not belong to Tecmilenio University,
when accessing to them, you must accept their terms and conditions.
Automated Storage and Retrieval Systems (AS/RS)
AS/RS systems are defined as an automated system for storage and retrieval (or delivery) of materials in a manufacturing process. The AS/RS uses a fixed system of rails along which an electromechanical arm runs in X, Z coordinates to reach the bays (also called bays), where the electromechanical arm can rotate and move along the Y axis to store or retrieve (S/R) the materials.
Automated storage and retrieval systems (AS/RS) have taken manufacturing and warehousing processes to the next level, combining computer technologies, process automation and warehousing logistics. The first use of AS/RS systems was only for finished goods, but their use has expanded to storage of raw materials, work-in-process (WIP) as well as tooling for manufacturing.
AS/RS systems have also affected the design of warehouses, for example, the racks used by AS/RS are often built to support not only the products, but to support the walls of the buildings that house the warehouses, resulting in a reduction in the cost of manufacturing a plant's buildings.
According to Groover (2018), the types of AS/RS can be the following (chart 3):
Type of AS/RS |
Characteristic |
Unit Load AS/RS |
System designed to handle unit loads stored on platforms or in standardized containers. The system is computer controlled and the S/R machines are automated and designed to handle the containers. |
Deep-Lane AS/RS |
Deep-Lane AS/RS systems are appropriate when large quantities of stock are stored, but the number of SKUs (Stock Keeping Unit) is relatively small. In this system, one load is stored one after the other. Loads are picked from one side of the rack by a type of S/R machine designed for retrieval, and another machine is used on the entry side of the rack for load entry. |
Miniload AS/RS |
Miniload AS/RS systems are used to handle small quantities of parts that are stored in crates. The S/R structure is designed to retrieve the crate and deliver it to a P/D station (pickup-and-deposit), where individual items are removed from the crates. Usually the P&D station is operated by a single operator. |
Man-On-Board AS/RS |
In this type of AS/RS, an operator is mounted on a basket that is moved to the lockers where the operator must deposit or pick up the materials. The AS/RS computing system moves the basket to the correct position. |
Automated Item Retrieval System |
This type of system is designed to store individual parts or small products; however, the products are deposited in containers which move on rails. In the system’s Automated Item Retrieval System, when an item needs to be retrieved, it is pushed onto the rail and dropped onto a conveyor for delivery to the picking station. The system is periodically refilled from the back side, allowing for first-in/first-out inventory turnover. |
Vertical Lift Storage Modules (VLSM) |
These systems, also known as (VL-AS/RS), differ from all previous models in that their boxes are distributed vertically rather than horizontally along a corridor. Due to the vertical configuration, these systems can reach 10 meters in height or more. |
Table 3. Types of AS/RS systems
AS/RS systems have different components for their operation, among which the most important are shown below (figure 5).
Figure 5. Structure of an AS/RS system
Groover, M. (2018). Automation Production System and Computer Integrated Manufacturing (5th ed.). United States: Pearson.
educational purposes only.
Conveyor belts (conveyors)
Conveyors can be divided into two categories based on the type of power they use.
Energized conveyors can be divided into two categories.
In turn, energized conveyor belts can be classified based on their travel into:
Conveyor belt calculations
The time required to move a part from start to finish in a one-way conveyor belt is given by the following formulas.
Where:
Td = Delivery time (min)
Ld = Conveyor length (m, ft)
Vc = Conveyor speed (m/min, ft/min)
An essential requirement for conveyor belts is that the unloading time must be equal or less than the charging time.
Where:
Tu = Time unloading (min/part)
TL = Time loading (min/part)
The following formula can be used to calculate the average material flow on a conveyor belt.
Where:
Rf = Frequency or flow of the material (parts/min)
RL = Load average (parts/min)
np = Number of parts per load
Vc = Conveyor speed (m/min, ft/min)
Sc = center-center distance between loads. (m/pcs, ft/pcs)
TL = Loading time for parts (min/parts)
Support systems play a very important role in manufacturing systems, there is a wide area of knowledge for each of the technologies that compose them: CAD, CAM, CAE, vision systems, automatic systems for storage and material handling. As an engineer you must have the knowledge and mastery of each of these technologies and be able to improve manufacturing processes.
Support technologies are constantly being renewed to find new ways to make tasks more economical, faster, more flexible, with the lowest energy consumption and with the highest possible capabilities.
Support systems can represent a fairly high cost for companies, but it is a necessary investment, given that without them, they would be very unproductive and would lose the market quickly, even until closing. It is important to evaluate the needs of each company to decide which of all the options on the market is the most convenient, for example, in CAD systems alone you can find a huge variety of similar software on the market. Which one to buy? Well, that depends on an analysis that, as an engineer, you will have to carry out make the best decision.Make sure that you:
The following links do not belong to Tecmilenio University, when accessing to them, you must accept their terms and conditions.
To learn more about automated material handling systems, watch the following video:
To learn more about computer vision in manufacturing, watch the following video:
To learn more about Siemens NX, watch the following video:
To learn more about computer vision in manufacturing, we recommend reading:
To learn more about machine vision, we recommend reading:
To learn more about automated storage, we recommend reading:
To learn more about CAD and CAE, we recommend reading :
Through a search and analysis of the information, the student will consolidate the topics covered in class on manufacturing support systems.
To learn about the software and hardware technologies that integrate manufacturing support systems.
Groover, M. (2018). Automation Production System and Computer Integrated Manufacturing (5th ed.). United States: Pearson.
Instructions
Individually
Deliverable(s)
A document with the development of the activity.
Evaluation criteria
Description
Solve exercises on material transport systems and answer a questionnaire with review questions.
Instructions
Individually
Determine.
Deliverable(s)
Submit a written report of the three activities.